|The Obama Double Standard on Civilian Casualties
Posted: 06 May 2015 11:57 AM PDT
…I don’t expect anything of people who think U.S. drone strikes are no less evil than Israel’s actions in Gaza. But the Obama Administration routinely defends its own civilian casualties as honest mistakes that occurred despite the strictest precautions. And to do that while simultaneously insisting that Israel’s can’t possibly be the same is the height of hypocrisy.
I know it’s been a busy two weeks, but I’m still waiting for that apology. I’ve been waiting for it ever since the U.S. admitted on April 23 to accidentally killing two Western hostages in Pakistan, and doubly so after a U.S. airstrike allegedly killed 52 civilians in Syria last Friday. Clearly, I don’t expect an apology for the fact that American forces are composed of men rather than angels, and therefore sometimes makes mistakes. But I certainly do expect an apology for the Obama Administration’s refusal to acknowledge that so are Israel’s forces. In the administration’s view, Israel never makes honest mistakes. If Israel inadvertently kills civilians in wartime, then it wasn’t trying hard enough not to do so.
We don’t yet know what happened in Syria, but the drone strike on an al-Qaeda compound in Pakistan is instructive. Administration officials told the New York Times that the CIA had “no idea that the hostages were being held there despite hundreds of hours of surveillance.” Yet they apparently can’t conceive of Israel — in the midst of a shooting war where decisions on whether to return fire must be made instantly, rather than with the benefit of hundreds of hours of surveillance — being similarly unaware that civilians were present at various sites it targeted during last summer’s war with Hamas in Gaza.
Needless to say, American military professionals don’t share the administration’s view. The day after the White House announced the hostages’ deaths; Michael Schmitt and John Merriam published a summary of their detailed investigation into Israel’s targeting practices during that war. Schmitt, a professor of international law, heads the Stockton Center for the Study of International Law at the U.S. Naval War College and is considered a leading expert on the laws of armed conflict (LOAC). Merriam is a U.S. Army Judge Advocate and associate director of the Stockton Center. They were given unusual access to information, like targeting procedures that the Israel Defense Forces usually keeps secret; they were also allowed to observe IDF targeting cells at work and examine combat footage that hasn’t been publicly released. And here’s their conclusion:
They also pointed out that “the nuances of the Israeli approach … can only be understood in the context of the specific operational and strategic environment in which the IDF must fight.” And the complexities of that environment, which Israel’s critics largely ignore, go beyond such simple facts as Hamas’s penchant for launching rockets from civilian homes.
For instance, one key principle of LOAC is proportionality, meaning that an attack is illegal if the anticipated harm to civilians is disproportionate to the anticipated military benefit. But for a country that routinely trades hundreds of terrorists – who then resume killing Israelis – for a single captured soldier, the anticipated military benefit of preventing a soldier from being captured may be much higher than it would be for countries that don’t routinely make such trades, Schmitt and Merriam noted.
Yet the professionals’ view – also voiced by Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Martin Dempsey last November – never mattered to their civilian superiors. Even a Pentagon spokesman joined the administration pile-on accusing Israel of callous disregard for civilian life, declaring in a news briefing last July that “the Israelis need to do more to live up to their very high standards … for protecting civilian life.”
I don’t expect anything of people who think U.S. drone strikes are no less evil than Israel’s actions in Gaza. But the Obama Administration routinely defends its own civilian casualties as honest mistakes that occurred despite the strictest precautions. And to do that while simultaneously insisting that Israel’s can’t possibly be the same is the height of hypocrisy.
Operation American Spring – May 16, 2014
Operation American Spring – May 16, 2014
- Proposed Constitution for The United States – Written in 1974
- Muslim Eddie Deen Preys on a Naive and Trusting Christian
- You MUST See President Trump’s Border Wall VIDEO
- You Won’t BELIEVE What NBC Tweeted about Robots and Pedophiles
- The Third Jihad – Radical Islam’s Vision for America – A Clarion Project Film
- Verizon just awoke the fury of the internet
- SCOTUS Alert: Prayer Banned
- ActBlue,, AN ORGANIZATION THAT NEEDS TO BE SHUT DOWN!!!
- Watch the untold story of true American heroes
- Subscribe and follow this woman: “THEY ARE COMING FOR THIS—America, We Are At A DIRE Turning Point, Resistance Is Key!”
- O’Keefe Strikes Again, Catches NYT Editors On Hidden Camera: “Targeting Trump’s Businesses, His Dumb F**k Of A Son”
- “Who was Stephen Paddock – the Alleged Las Vegas Shooter?” or How can a dead man shoot people in Las Vegas…Maybe the CIA and FBI should stop covert gun sales to terrorist groups.
- What are the odds Las Vegas shooting was a false flag? UPDATED
- More red flags…
- Las Vegas Shooting: 4chan Exposes Those Set to Make Huge Profits from Attacks – Criminal masterminds exposed behind the scenes of attacks
- Islamists Footage of Stephen Paddock and Girlfriend at an Anti-Trump Protest?
- New post Former Clinton Aide Kept Three Muslim Women As Sex Slaves
- New post Young Girl Faces Criminal Charges For ‘Luring’ Pedophile To Rape Her
- Can’t be done eh? Israel’s Southern Border Fence 100 Percent Effective in Preventing Illegals from Infiltra ting
- She is delusional! Fw: Rochester’s Pioneering Role
- Are you a DACA recipient?
- Sep 10, 2017 A tribute for the 16th anniversary of 9/11/2001
- YOU WERE THERE….I FOR ONE WILL NEVER FORGET YOUR BRAVERY AND SACRIFICE
- 9/11: 15th Anniversary Tribute (2001-2016)
- 9-11 Tribute songs – View full playlist (80 videos)
- We Have Forgoten! September 11, 2017 – Fake News Claims There Have Been No Attacks On The US – THEY LIE!
- Absolutely NO!!! Fw: A bipartisan win
- Crosses and Bibles Being Forcibly Taken Off Christian Churches. This is how the Christian Persicutions began in Africa and now Europe!
- Are We In The End Times?
- Bubonic plague found in Arizona ticks, fleas
- Charlottesville Video and Stills From Video: Watch the car getting its drivers window smashed out
- STEVEN LEE LAVENDER
- I support this! 35 States already are on board! It only takes 38 (of the 50) States to convene a Constitutional Convention. This will give you something to think about.
- CALLING ALL PATRIOTS: Rise and Fight For the Country You Love
- New Zeal Blog: SNOPES TAKEN HOSTAGE: Left-wing “fact-checker” reveals it has lost control of its website
- WND EXCLUSIVE Rabbi claims his Bible code links Scripture to calendar
- Obama Is Still Not Off the Hook For Gun Running Scandal That Killed Border Agent
- Shooter in Bronx-Lebanon Hospital – Dr Henry Bello – Nigerian Native
- Young John Wayne
- Philippe Petit – The Young Man Who Gave The Twin Tower Life And Love In 1974
- This is actually what America would look like without gerrymandering
- University Of Texas Stabber Reenacted White Genocide – 14-minute, poorly produced video at his home that shows Kendrex White and his classmates reenacting the murder of white people by Haitian political figure Dutty Boukman
- What Chuck Schumer is revealing out in the open
- Trump to CBS’s Dickerson: ‘I Love Your Show — I Call It Deface the Nation’
- ‘What the hell?’: TV screens go dark as Spectrum cuts channels, raises prices
- Obama makes $400K for speech at A&E event: report
- FULL TRANSCRIPT: President Donald Trump’s interview with “Face the Nation” (This is good)
- What Chuck Schumer is revealing out in the open
- Scotland: Priest Fired After Objecting To Anti-Jesus Muslim Prayer
- Gavin McInnes: Hear me read Ann Coulter’s “banned” speech, like I just did in Berkeley
- THE REBEL MEDIA: BOMBSHELL: Inside Canada-USA “Refugee” Trafficking Ring
- Lincoln’s Hard Hand of War ~ “Brion McClanahan on an American dictator killing his own people.”- LewRockwell
- Muslim men can rape non-Muslim women to teach them a lesson, claims woman Islamic professor
- Why the Aleutian Islands of Alaska should be reclaimed from Russia in Obama illegal land give-away!
- Aposte Hirsi Ali: We Must Reach out to the Reformers
- Project Veritas: Ask Trump to Unleash Project Veritas
- New Law Means You Could be the Subject of a Vaccine or Medication Experiment Without Your Informed Consent (One last Christmas surprise from President Obama.)
- Former CIA officer: Flynn fired over high-level DC pedophile list
- MICHAEL SAVAGE NEWSLETTER: How about Obama’s meddling in 4 foreign elections?
- Thursday Morning: Logan’s Warning Live on the Captain’s AMERICA Radio Show! Via AM 860
- Reflections On A Funeral, And What The Hell Is Going On???
- Clarion Project: Changing America to Suit Islam Helps Muslims Integrate
- MORE FAKE NEWS (LIES) FROM LOUISE “SLAUGHTER THE CHILDREN”! his ‘woman’ should be IN JAIL!!!
- New Zeal Blog: It’s Time to Impeach the Judges
- Here’s What The Prosecutors in the Bundy Ranch Case Didn’t Want the Court To See Or Hear (Video & Pictures)
- Radical Erdogan Builds 9000 Mosques & Bans Christian Liturgy
- Dear Liberals
- Fascinating animation shows immigration into United States since 1820
- Empty Tent City in Saudi Arabia!!!
- It’s the LAW — BAN ISLAM IN THE USA
- UPDATE:::2nd UPDATE::::Hungary’s Prime Minister is fed up with Muslim Migrants destroying his country PLUS Kuwait Imposes Visa Ban on Five Muslim-Majority Countries PLUS ‘Time to act’ Italy calls for mass migrant deportations as half a million refugees arrive
- Pastor, Eight Others Missing in Uganda after Muslims Beat, Rape Congregation Throng of about 90 attacks prayer meeting of 80.
- The Truth About Trump’s ‘Muslim Ban’
- Slaughter does not care for opposition voices: Resistance Toolkit
- New Leaked Documents Reveal Expansive Soros Funding to Manipulate U.S. Elections
- Heads Up! FEMA Is Preparing Communities for ‘Complex Coordinated Terror Attacks’ – YouTube
- *** UPDATE*** gotnews.com: BREAKING: Records Suggest #FortLauderdale Shooter #EstebanSantiago Is Puerto Rican Islamic Terrorist & Anime Fan
- Is this YOUR future?
- Official: Suspected Gunman Told FBI He Was Being Forced To Fight For ISIS
- Debt collapse ‘perfect storm’ shaping up that will almost instantly wipe out pension funds nationwide
- Judas Glenn Beck Makes Anti Trump Alliance With Far Left
- Ed Boston Podcast
- Who is Keith Ellison (Hakim Muhammad as he declared in a foreign magazine article)? Keith Hakim, Keith X Ellison, and Keith Ellison-Muhammad? What name is his real one?
- Fast And Furious Friday!! 11-11-2016 11/11 by HOV Radio | Politics Conservative Podcasts
- Election Night Extravaganza, Part Deux! 11/09 by English Defence League Radio | Politics Conservative Podcasts
- ELECTION 2016 EXTRAVAGANZA!! 11/08 by Red Fox Blogger | Politics Conservative Podcasts
- WANTED FOT HIGH TREASON
- Wikileaks ‘Doomsday Machine’ Now Triggered, Will It Bring Down The Entire United States Government?
- The Danger Zone: Why Israel Greatly Fears Barack Obama’s Last Few Months In Office
- As Obamacare implodes, this candidate wants to serve as a SUICIDE CULT leader for America
- Acetaminophen—the main ingredient in Tylenol
- New Zeal Blog: Obama’s Reckless Plan Threatens U.S. Oversight of Internet
- New Zeal Blog: Trevor Loudon presents “Enemies Within” Florida screenings
- MYSTERIOUS Structures Have Been Revealed in Satellite Photos.. Government Chiefs Wants Banned
- Rothschild Insider Warned of an Elite Planned Race War in America
- Obama At United Nations Calls For America To Be ‘Bound By International Laws’ Give Up Control
- Now that’s a time bomb! 700-year-old hand grenade used in the Crusades is found off the coast of Israel
- The Free Thought Project Newsletter
- VOTE 2016 – HOLGER FOR PRESIDENT
- The Strange Tale of the First Woman to Run for President
- 651,170 hits
Be a Mosquebuster – grab a button for your website
- Follow a12iggymom's Blog on WordPress.com
Follow me on TwitterMy Tweets